Referees who throw matches make strategic decisions to award decisions against the team they want to win. So they send off a player in the last few minutes when the impact will be small or give free-kicks in less advantageous positions for the opposition than the decisions they give their favoured team just so the stats look fair.
Some people might think Jeremy Hunt does this when he uses the defence that he made 4 decisions that made James Murdoch 'furious' when it was quite plain that but for the Milly Dowler affair and resulting furore the BSkyB bid was going to be waved through. Also notice how Rupert 'forgets' meeting PMs and other politicians but remembers other minute details. Does anybody really believe these guys are telling the truth? I wonder.
Showing posts with label Crime And Security. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crime And Security. Show all posts
25 April 2012
06 June 2010
Switzerland Has 10 Times The Number Of Gun Deaths As UK.
I am sick and tired of hearing that Switzerland proves that high gun ownership is safe (Andrew Neil repeated the myth on This Week in the Cumbria massacre debate).
The Swiss helpfully don't keep records of gun deaths which is handy for gun nuts (a case of fingers in ears) but international surveys have shown that they do not have some magical low gun death figure.
As a prosperous country with little social problems you would expect that this would give them lower gun deaths than the US despite having higher gun ownership, but compared to the UK, the Swiss are shooting each other in droves. Lets kill this stupid right-wing lie.
The Swiss helpfully don't keep records of gun deaths which is handy for gun nuts (a case of fingers in ears) but international surveys have shown that they do not have some magical low gun death figure.
As a prosperous country with little social problems you would expect that this would give them lower gun deaths than the US despite having higher gun ownership, but compared to the UK, the Swiss are shooting each other in droves. Lets kill this stupid right-wing lie.
04 June 2010
Our Supposedly 'Tough Gun Laws' Are A Joke.
This is a response to Paul Burgin's post on the Cumbria Massacre.
Paul, what possible justification is there for a taxi driver to have these sorts of weapons at home?
The equation seems simple to me. If we want to reduce these incidents from once a decade to perhaps once every 20-30 years, we need to reduce the 600,000 gun licences we issue and the 1.7 million legally owned weapons swilling around out there.
As our glorious leader DC says, 'a flick of a switch' in anyone of these 600,000 and it will happen again. When you consider 1 in 4 of us will suffer severe depression or mental illness in our lives, we are taking one hell of a risk dishing out this many legal weapons into the community. We have to ask ourselves is the 'right' to shoot animals or play games shooting clay disks worth this sort of risk? I think we are mad to tolerate the gun lobby having fun playing with guns and putting us all at risk. (Oh, and just to add, there is no way someone could inflict such carnage with a bread knife etc. and anyone who argues that is simply being absurd).
As for having 'tough gun laws', I think they are a joke. This guy had a criminal conviction and apparently legal gun owners can go 10 years and no-one will check their home or that their mental health is still ok. Even in the gun-happy US, this guy would never have got a licence. Apply for a gun here and you can even refuse to let the police see your medical records. It is ridiculous.
Paul, what possible justification is there for a taxi driver to have these sorts of weapons at home?
The equation seems simple to me. If we want to reduce these incidents from once a decade to perhaps once every 20-30 years, we need to reduce the 600,000 gun licences we issue and the 1.7 million legally owned weapons swilling around out there.
As our glorious leader DC says, 'a flick of a switch' in anyone of these 600,000 and it will happen again. When you consider 1 in 4 of us will suffer severe depression or mental illness in our lives, we are taking one hell of a risk dishing out this many legal weapons into the community. We have to ask ourselves is the 'right' to shoot animals or play games shooting clay disks worth this sort of risk? I think we are mad to tolerate the gun lobby having fun playing with guns and putting us all at risk. (Oh, and just to add, there is no way someone could inflict such carnage with a bread knife etc. and anyone who argues that is simply being absurd).
As for having 'tough gun laws', I think they are a joke. This guy had a criminal conviction and apparently legal gun owners can go 10 years and no-one will check their home or that their mental health is still ok. Even in the gun-happy US, this guy would never have got a licence. Apply for a gun here and you can even refuse to let the police see your medical records. It is ridiculous.
03 June 2010
...And The Tories Want To Legalise Handguns.
My comment to Charlotte Gore after her post on the Cumbria Massacre.
Charlotte, of course this will happen again. Legislation on handguns has made gun deaths rare, but clearly we can go much further – there are 1.3 MILLION weapons of this sort lying around in people’s homes LEGALLY. The question should be ‘why does a taxi driver need to legally own these weapons and keep them in his home?’
The answer to me, seems pretty simple. Either we shrug our shoulders and say as you have ’shit happens’ or we remove the right to own these dangerous weapons and it won’t happen so often.
One in four of us will suffer serious depression and mental illness in our lives. We all get angry at times, a lot of people with no criminal records occasionally get violent. Having these guns in the home is just asking for trouble.
Banning handguns has reduced the risk, restricting ownership of shotguns and rifles and placing more guns in secure army storage would perhaps make these tragedies happen every 20 years instead of 10.
Offering a short amnesty where the government pays more than the market rate for these weapons could remove millions of these guns both legal and illegal off the streets. Even if this amnesty cost a billion pounds it would be worth it.
David Cameron came into this last election promising to loosen regulation of handguns. Thankfully the Tories might not be able to do that now.
Charlotte, of course this will happen again. Legislation on handguns has made gun deaths rare, but clearly we can go much further – there are 1.3 MILLION weapons of this sort lying around in people’s homes LEGALLY. The question should be ‘why does a taxi driver need to legally own these weapons and keep them in his home?’
The answer to me, seems pretty simple. Either we shrug our shoulders and say as you have ’shit happens’ or we remove the right to own these dangerous weapons and it won’t happen so often.
One in four of us will suffer serious depression and mental illness in our lives. We all get angry at times, a lot of people with no criminal records occasionally get violent. Having these guns in the home is just asking for trouble.
Banning handguns has reduced the risk, restricting ownership of shotguns and rifles and placing more guns in secure army storage would perhaps make these tragedies happen every 20 years instead of 10.
Offering a short amnesty where the government pays more than the market rate for these weapons could remove millions of these guns both legal and illegal off the streets. Even if this amnesty cost a billion pounds it would be worth it.
David Cameron came into this last election promising to loosen regulation of handguns. Thankfully the Tories might not be able to do that now.
13 May 2010
ID Cards & ID register ConDem'd. NO2ID rejoice.
I don't think this will make a blind bit of difference to our civil liberties. It will save some money theoretically but in practise not much, as a lot of money has already been spent, or will be spent in closing it down.
I also think even the ConDem government will embrace new technology in the end. CCTV has had an impact on crime, people are being caught because of it, ditto the DNA database which has not only captured criminals who would never have been caught but actually enhanced our liberties by proving innocence of those already convicted or accused of crimes.
A lot of NO2ID propaganda is about technophobia, not all of it, but a lot. There is far more surveillance by the private sector than by the government. Somehow this is strangely more accepted by NO2ID and the general population. Perhaps its the fact the Tory fanzine press are obsessed with anything negative about a government when their people don't control it and the private companies spend billions to tell us how nice they are in the same Tory press, which buys the media silence.
I also think even the ConDem government will embrace new technology in the end. CCTV has had an impact on crime, people are being caught because of it, ditto the DNA database which has not only captured criminals who would never have been caught but actually enhanced our liberties by proving innocence of those already convicted or accused of crimes.
A lot of NO2ID propaganda is about technophobia, not all of it, but a lot. There is far more surveillance by the private sector than by the government. Somehow this is strangely more accepted by NO2ID and the general population. Perhaps its the fact the Tory fanzine press are obsessed with anything negative about a government when their people don't control it and the private companies spend billions to tell us how nice they are in the same Tory press, which buys the media silence.
15 May 2009
Prime Ministerial, My Ar**!
The Tory press are trying to big up Mr Cameron as 'prime ministerial' because a couple of his MPs and shadow ministers have promised to pay back a little of what they have robbed from us.
Cameron with his 20k mortgage interest at our expense and his 140k salary at our expense is only looking good in comparison to Gordon Brown who has put in a woeful performance. Cameron is not looking prime ministerial unless to look like a PM you have to be a cocky arrogant git as incompetent as the present incumbent.
All MPs on the scam should not get away with this and that includes slimy Cameron and Osbourne. Why has Julie Kirkbride got away with claiming for a second home her husband also claimed for, for example? QUARTER OF A MILLION POUNDS this pair of Tory no goods have cost us taxpayers!!
How could cleaning your moat, repairing your tennis courts and swimming pools and sheer tax avoidance ever be 'wholly necessary' for being an MP? Only if you were a crook would it be necessary. In fact does it surprise anyone that on the Labour benches Tony McNulty, Hazel Blears and Gordon Brown are crooks and that Tories like Hogg, Kilbride, Cameron and countless others are crooks. It is always the slimy right wing types in both the Labour and Tory party likely to be on the fiddle. To be fair to the Lib Dems, their dubious claims only involve a few hundred quid not thousands or even millions in some cases.
It is a real shame these expenses claims only go back to 2005 when apparently the 'rules were tightened', god knows what the dodgy Tory ministers were claiming for in the 80s and 90s from when Thatcher changed the rules!! I wonder whether David Mellor would sound so moral on radio 5 if that were known.
The real shame is that we don't have a proportional system which gives power back to voters. Under the present system MPs like Douglas Hogg and his moat will survive while Celia Barlow and Martin Salter - hard working MPs who have not claimed a penny, will lose their seats
Cameron with his 20k mortgage interest at our expense and his 140k salary at our expense is only looking good in comparison to Gordon Brown who has put in a woeful performance. Cameron is not looking prime ministerial unless to look like a PM you have to be a cocky arrogant git as incompetent as the present incumbent.
All MPs on the scam should not get away with this and that includes slimy Cameron and Osbourne. Why has Julie Kirkbride got away with claiming for a second home her husband also claimed for, for example? QUARTER OF A MILLION POUNDS this pair of Tory no goods have cost us taxpayers!!
How could cleaning your moat, repairing your tennis courts and swimming pools and sheer tax avoidance ever be 'wholly necessary' for being an MP? Only if you were a crook would it be necessary. In fact does it surprise anyone that on the Labour benches Tony McNulty, Hazel Blears and Gordon Brown are crooks and that Tories like Hogg, Kilbride, Cameron and countless others are crooks. It is always the slimy right wing types in both the Labour and Tory party likely to be on the fiddle. To be fair to the Lib Dems, their dubious claims only involve a few hundred quid not thousands or even millions in some cases.
It is a real shame these expenses claims only go back to 2005 when apparently the 'rules were tightened', god knows what the dodgy Tory ministers were claiming for in the 80s and 90s from when Thatcher changed the rules!! I wonder whether David Mellor would sound so moral on radio 5 if that were known.
The real shame is that we don't have a proportional system which gives power back to voters. Under the present system MPs like Douglas Hogg and his moat will survive while Celia Barlow and Martin Salter - hard working MPs who have not claimed a penny, will lose their seats
No Ifs, No Buts..
I don't see any difference between what MPs have been doing with their expenses claims and benefit fraud.
Do we think someone who was caught overclaiming on their housing benefit could claim it was an 'innocent mistake' and avoid a criminal record? I think not, 'no ifs, no buts' as the advert told us. It is a pity the same rules do not apply to MPs.
Do we think someone who was caught overclaiming on their housing benefit could claim it was an 'innocent mistake' and avoid a criminal record? I think not, 'no ifs, no buts' as the advert told us. It is a pity the same rules do not apply to MPs.
05 May 2009
We all have something to hide.
I have thought long and hard about the mantra 'if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear'. This is sometimes used by proponents of ID/CCTV/DNA databases etc. It is not something i have ever felt the need to use.
Opponents of databases etc always sneer that the simplicity of this statement shows the simplicity of the proponent's argument and sometimes of the proponent. But this statement is not useless because it is wrong, it is because we ALL DO have something to fear.
It all stems from our deep seated fear of a 'snitch', 'grass', 'do gooder' etc. Even people who argue - both right and left - about the utmost importance of law and order are suspicious of people who 'shop' criminals, even if they recognise it is the correct thing to do.
Opponents prey on this anti-authority streak to advance their cause. Sometimes they are right, but sometimes they throw the baby out with the bathwater - think of Greens and nuclear power and unions who resist new technology and more efficiency. In the end they just hurt their own cause.
I am convinced that NO2ID and opponents of DNA databases ultimately will realise they have unwittingly damaged the cause of liberty and freedom. Deleting innocent people off the DNA database is a backward step when for fairness and accuracy we need to dna everybody. Only then will our justice system be able to become less punitive rather than an unfair hit and miss so called deterrent system.
*update* Jonathan Myerson writes in the Guardian on this very subject.
Opponents of databases etc always sneer that the simplicity of this statement shows the simplicity of the proponent's argument and sometimes of the proponent. But this statement is not useless because it is wrong, it is because we ALL DO have something to fear.
It all stems from our deep seated fear of a 'snitch', 'grass', 'do gooder' etc. Even people who argue - both right and left - about the utmost importance of law and order are suspicious of people who 'shop' criminals, even if they recognise it is the correct thing to do.
Opponents prey on this anti-authority streak to advance their cause. Sometimes they are right, but sometimes they throw the baby out with the bathwater - think of Greens and nuclear power and unions who resist new technology and more efficiency. In the end they just hurt their own cause.
I am convinced that NO2ID and opponents of DNA databases ultimately will realise they have unwittingly damaged the cause of liberty and freedom. Deleting innocent people off the DNA database is a backward step when for fairness and accuracy we need to dna everybody. Only then will our justice system be able to become less punitive rather than an unfair hit and miss so called deterrent system.
*update* Jonathan Myerson writes in the Guardian on this very subject.
16 April 2009
Prof Jeffries - I Agree It's Unfair.
Professor Sir Alec Jeffreys - the inventor of genetic fingerprinting thinks it unfair that some people are on the DNA database while others are not.
His crucial remark is in reply to the fact that keeping aquitted people on the database does help solve crimes;
I completely agree with this - it is unfair that some people are on the database and others are not because some rapists and murderers will be caught and others will escape merely because they have had no previous contact with police - which could be more about the prejudices of police and societal actions rather than individual actions.
The argument is that those arrested and aquitted are an unrepresentative section of the population who are being 'punished' by having their details held despite not being convicted of any crime.
It is certainly correct that the prejudices of society can decide who ends up on the database. But if we follow this logic through shouldn't convicted criminals also have their details relinquished? Because they too tend to over-represent certain groups.
It seems to me what is unfair is that some people are treated differently to others and if we are to have a DNA database at all and be fair to all then we have to put EVERYONE on it.
We have to look at this new technology as we would any other technology - we wouldn't say we will only consult mobile phone evidence or CCTV evidence for people who have previous. The fact is we don't know who is going to be guilty and who isn't by their previous actions - that is prejudging people, i.e. prejudice. The only way around this is to treat everyone the same and have everyone on the DNA register.
The other concerns of Prof Jeffries relate to other matters. Of course it is a scandal if people are not allowed a re-test to confirm results - there will obviously be mistakes on the database and also with testing. And of course, as I always state - DNA is only one avenue of evidence and not conclusive, it needs to be backed up with other evidence. None of this affects the argument about who should be on the database and who shouldn't.
Finally if there is a 'stigma' about being on the database, of being 'branded as criminal', surely if everyone was on it, rather than just convicted criminals and those unfortunate enough to be picked on by police when completely innocent of any crime, then surely any stigma would disappear.
There is one thing that would be certain, if everyone was on the database - there would be less rapists and murderers going unpunished and more innocent people set free.
I sometimes suspect that opposition to the DNA database has more to do with the fact that middle class people and people of 'standing' will be treated the same as the rest of us plebs, rather than anything to do with real civil liberties.
If you look at cases - even the very first case showed that the person the police wanted to 'fit up' for the crime was proved innocent by DNA evidence and someone who was completely unsuspected was found. Putting everyone on the database is more likely to prove innocence and bring the actual culprits to justice. What is wrong with that?
His crucial remark is in reply to the fact that keeping aquitted people on the database does help solve crimes;
"If you just dumped a few hundred thousand people at random on the database you would get the same effect
I completely agree with this - it is unfair that some people are on the database and others are not because some rapists and murderers will be caught and others will escape merely because they have had no previous contact with police - which could be more about the prejudices of police and societal actions rather than individual actions.
The argument is that those arrested and aquitted are an unrepresentative section of the population who are being 'punished' by having their details held despite not being convicted of any crime.
It is certainly correct that the prejudices of society can decide who ends up on the database. But if we follow this logic through shouldn't convicted criminals also have their details relinquished? Because they too tend to over-represent certain groups.
It seems to me what is unfair is that some people are treated differently to others and if we are to have a DNA database at all and be fair to all then we have to put EVERYONE on it.
We have to look at this new technology as we would any other technology - we wouldn't say we will only consult mobile phone evidence or CCTV evidence for people who have previous. The fact is we don't know who is going to be guilty and who isn't by their previous actions - that is prejudging people, i.e. prejudice. The only way around this is to treat everyone the same and have everyone on the DNA register.
The other concerns of Prof Jeffries relate to other matters. Of course it is a scandal if people are not allowed a re-test to confirm results - there will obviously be mistakes on the database and also with testing. And of course, as I always state - DNA is only one avenue of evidence and not conclusive, it needs to be backed up with other evidence. None of this affects the argument about who should be on the database and who shouldn't.
Finally if there is a 'stigma' about being on the database, of being 'branded as criminal', surely if everyone was on it, rather than just convicted criminals and those unfortunate enough to be picked on by police when completely innocent of any crime, then surely any stigma would disappear.
There is one thing that would be certain, if everyone was on the database - there would be less rapists and murderers going unpunished and more innocent people set free.
I sometimes suspect that opposition to the DNA database has more to do with the fact that middle class people and people of 'standing' will be treated the same as the rest of us plebs, rather than anything to do with real civil liberties.
If you look at cases - even the very first case showed that the person the police wanted to 'fit up' for the crime was proved innocent by DNA evidence and someone who was completely unsuspected was found. Putting everyone on the database is more likely to prove innocence and bring the actual culprits to justice. What is wrong with that?
12 April 2009
On Liberty - Safety in Numbers
John Stuart Mill's seminal 'On Liberty' was published 150 years ago.
Mill asserted the sovereignty of the individual over 'majority tyranny' on condition an individual's actions caused 'no harm' to others.
It is the definition of what constitutes harm that has concerned liberals ever since and it led Mill to some very anti-democratic conclusions.
No principle or ideology is uncontentious and when libertarian fundamentalists hold a principle as sancrosanct, this is where they stray into dangerous territory. Neither ID cards, DNA databases or CCTV is all bad (or all good). In essence these technological advances are neutral - they can be used for good or bad - as I have been trying to point out, it is access and control that are important.
I think the recent video of a policeman assaulting Ian Tomlinson at the G20 protest demonstrates how universality of control can make video surveillance a very good social tool for good - as this CIF article argues. My motto on this is 'safety in numbers' - when information is available to all it is more likely to protect than harm. Common sense dictates that no one piece of information is seen as conclusive but in conjunction with a range of information it is more likely to prove innocence than guilt (think DNA, CCTV, mobile phone, internet records combined -just one could prove that someone was not present at the scene of a crime, and yet several are needed pointing to guilt and this strengthens the likelyhood that the evidence is correct).
It is right to say that the slogan 'if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear' is a poor defence of surveillance. But not for the reasons opponents of CCTV, ID cards etc try to make out. We all have something to hide and maybe even fear however minor the indiscretion, but this does not mean that bringing these indiscretions out into the open is a bad thing.
At the moment, punishment for lawbreaking tends to be overly severe in an attempt to 'deter' and haphazard targeting leads to the usual disadvantaged groups unfairly bearing the brunt of society's ire. If detection were much more likely, punishments could be much more realistic for the lesser crimes that most commit. The middle class would not like being treated like everyone else which explains the hostility of the Daily Mail, Express et all, and also the hostility of middle class bloggers, but we should not fall for that distortion of big brother that Orwell inadvertantly made seem overly threatening. Human rights should mean protection for all, not just for the powerful.
Mill asserted the sovereignty of the individual over 'majority tyranny' on condition an individual's actions caused 'no harm' to others.
It is the definition of what constitutes harm that has concerned liberals ever since and it led Mill to some very anti-democratic conclusions.
No principle or ideology is uncontentious and when libertarian fundamentalists hold a principle as sancrosanct, this is where they stray into dangerous territory. Neither ID cards, DNA databases or CCTV is all bad (or all good). In essence these technological advances are neutral - they can be used for good or bad - as I have been trying to point out, it is access and control that are important.
I think the recent video of a policeman assaulting Ian Tomlinson at the G20 protest demonstrates how universality of control can make video surveillance a very good social tool for good - as this CIF article argues. My motto on this is 'safety in numbers' - when information is available to all it is more likely to protect than harm. Common sense dictates that no one piece of information is seen as conclusive but in conjunction with a range of information it is more likely to prove innocence than guilt (think DNA, CCTV, mobile phone, internet records combined -just one could prove that someone was not present at the scene of a crime, and yet several are needed pointing to guilt and this strengthens the likelyhood that the evidence is correct).
It is right to say that the slogan 'if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear' is a poor defence of surveillance. But not for the reasons opponents of CCTV, ID cards etc try to make out. We all have something to hide and maybe even fear however minor the indiscretion, but this does not mean that bringing these indiscretions out into the open is a bad thing.
At the moment, punishment for lawbreaking tends to be overly severe in an attempt to 'deter' and haphazard targeting leads to the usual disadvantaged groups unfairly bearing the brunt of society's ire. If detection were much more likely, punishments could be much more realistic for the lesser crimes that most commit. The middle class would not like being treated like everyone else which explains the hostility of the Daily Mail, Express et all, and also the hostility of middle class bloggers, but we should not fall for that distortion of big brother that Orwell inadvertantly made seem overly threatening. Human rights should mean protection for all, not just for the powerful.
08 April 2009
Police - Finally Caught On Camera Lying Through Their Teeth!
What gets me is that there are still some commenters willing to defend the police after this incident and the police's outright lies - they have been caught red handed - funny no mainstream tv or right-wing rag seem interested in reporting the story (imagine if some anarchist had beaten up a policeman - would have been repeated on news shows and front pages for weeks).
First the police make out they helped Tomlinson (who later collapsed and died) and that the crowd had thrown missiles at medics helping him, a claim they later withdraw - now we have video evidence of them needlessly hitting the guy and pushing him to the ground - and still this is not concrete enough evidence for some people (see comments to pickled politics post) of police wrongdoing.
Remember the propaganda put out about the De-Menezes death - that he was carrying a rucksack, running away from police etc. - none of it in the least bit true. Then the CCTV mysteriously goes missing or is deemed inconclusive. This case would have headed the same way no doubt under the 'investigation' of the 'independent' police complaints authority.
Don't be surprised if no police officer is charged for this, the De-Menezes case shows that they can get away with murder because they are still above the law, even when caught red handed and lying through the teeth contradicting dozens of witness evidence and now maybe even video evidence as well. Maybe things were worse decades ago (I have heard stories from decent people beaten up by police that I found unbelievable at the time but now think are probably true) - but it seems they can still beat people up and get away with it. They are above the law.
24 January 2009
Stockwell
Wednesday night's drama 'Stockwell' on ITV1 brought together two of my biggest prejudices - my hatred for rubbish ITV and the incompetent arrogant police that we have. Prejudices which my wife would tell you make my judgement on this not worth much.
I am sure we can all agree that in the aftermath of the tube bombings and the failed bombers that were still on the loose - the police were under impossible pressure to deliver 'something' and that a catalog of failures by the police led to a tragedy - firearms officers late for work and faffing around wasting time, inadequate procedures to ensure proper surveillance, woeful communications, poor ID photo, an order 'from above' to 'shoot to kill' without clear guidelines of how to apply it. All of this could be forgiven by myself - we all make mistakes and hopefully learn from them.
What I cannot forgive though is the sense that the police were in any way 'protecting us' with their actions or that any of this was unavoidable or that individual police should avoid prosecution - all the officers involved are back in the same jobs (or promoted).
If De Menezes had been shot outside his flat - I could have understood how it maybe protected the public. If De Menezes had been carrying a bag I could understand him being shot dead on public transport - even though it was clear they gave him plenty of time to detonate any device if he had of been a terrorist .
What is clear to me is that this was a 'revenge' killing - a take that for the events of the previous week - an officer with anger in his eyes and a sense of needing to do 'something' murdered a member of the public who clearly was not carrying a bomb. Even with the right man - this operation would have protected no-one and coupled with the incompetence of the police it was almost bound to end up with an innocent man's death.
ITV have typically let the police off the hook with this poor examination of events and no real mention of the ensuing attempt at a cover up, yet alone the outright contradictory evidence from eyewitnesses present.
I am sure we can all agree that in the aftermath of the tube bombings and the failed bombers that were still on the loose - the police were under impossible pressure to deliver 'something' and that a catalog of failures by the police led to a tragedy - firearms officers late for work and faffing around wasting time, inadequate procedures to ensure proper surveillance, woeful communications, poor ID photo, an order 'from above' to 'shoot to kill' without clear guidelines of how to apply it. All of this could be forgiven by myself - we all make mistakes and hopefully learn from them.
What I cannot forgive though is the sense that the police were in any way 'protecting us' with their actions or that any of this was unavoidable or that individual police should avoid prosecution - all the officers involved are back in the same jobs (or promoted).
If De Menezes had been shot outside his flat - I could have understood how it maybe protected the public. If De Menezes had been carrying a bag I could understand him being shot dead on public transport - even though it was clear they gave him plenty of time to detonate any device if he had of been a terrorist .
What is clear to me is that this was a 'revenge' killing - a take that for the events of the previous week - an officer with anger in his eyes and a sense of needing to do 'something' murdered a member of the public who clearly was not carrying a bomb. Even with the right man - this operation would have protected no-one and coupled with the incompetence of the police it was almost bound to end up with an innocent man's death.
ITV have typically let the police off the hook with this poor examination of events and no real mention of the ensuing attempt at a cover up, yet alone the outright contradictory evidence from eyewitnesses present.
27 October 2008
Isn't It A Good Thing That People Are Drinking Less?
When Labour liberalised the licensing laws in 2005, the Tories and Lib Dems (some liberals they are!) predicted a binge drinking and violence epidemic, instead we find 3 years later that people are drinking nearly 20% less and violent crime is still falling (despite a cock up in the figures there is no disputing lower homicides and gun death figures).
For those who think the smoking ban accounts for lower beer sales, remember that the latest figures show not only an 8% drop in bar sales, but a 6% drop in supermarket sales as well.
Yes, the recession is playing its part, but...
For those who think the smoking ban accounts for lower beer sales, remember that the latest figures show not only an 8% drop in bar sales, but a 6% drop in supermarket sales as well.
Yes, the recession is playing its part, but...
beer sales started their downward trend in 2005 when economic growth was at its peak.
It seems whatever happens under a Labour government (beer sales up or down, traffic up or down, etc etc) will be printed as bad news in the Daily Mail, Torygraph, Express, Star, Sun, Times, Metro, Standard and all the other local press and media these foreign oligarchs own.
Stirring up nationalism, racism and xenophobia at home while buying our politicians with freebie holidays on foreign billionaire's yachts is so shameless you really do wonder how people like Rupert Murdoch, Lord Rothermere and others sleep at night. This sort of 'British' corruption may be done in a very polite fashion compared to the blatent continental type, but I am not sure it is any better.
Why do we not hear about Blair, Brown and Cameron's regular meeting with these media oligarchs? Because these oligarchs own the media that is why, but it doesn't make it any less corrupt.
See my previous post on state funding to find out how we stop this expensive silliness that damages our politics and costs the taxpayer billions in corruption - a simple ban on all donations over a £1000 a year and a tick box on the ballot paper to give people the choice to donate £3 a year to local political parties (or nothing at all if they tick nothing) as advocated by the Power Inquiry.
This is simple stuff and would put determining policies back in the hands of the electorate, not the rich elite. For the first time ever, low turn-out would hit parties financially - the incentive to drive up turn-out would be strong unlike at present where there might actually be an incentive to LOWER turn-out with negative tactics (favoured most by the Right). Add in a fair (proportional) voting system to fair funding - where every vote counts equally, and power really would be returned to the people - anyway enough dreaming - back to the reality of continual grind against the distorted system we have that delivers perpetual Tory and Labour governments that the majority vote against.
It seems whatever happens under a Labour government (beer sales up or down, traffic up or down, etc etc) will be printed as bad news in the Daily Mail, Torygraph, Express, Star, Sun, Times, Metro, Standard and all the other local press and media these foreign oligarchs own.
Stirring up nationalism, racism and xenophobia at home while buying our politicians with freebie holidays on foreign billionaire's yachts is so shameless you really do wonder how people like Rupert Murdoch, Lord Rothermere and others sleep at night. This sort of 'British' corruption may be done in a very polite fashion compared to the blatent continental type, but I am not sure it is any better.
Why do we not hear about Blair, Brown and Cameron's regular meeting with these media oligarchs? Because these oligarchs own the media that is why, but it doesn't make it any less corrupt.
See my previous post on state funding to find out how we stop this expensive silliness that damages our politics and costs the taxpayer billions in corruption - a simple ban on all donations over a £1000 a year and a tick box on the ballot paper to give people the choice to donate £3 a year to local political parties (or nothing at all if they tick nothing) as advocated by the Power Inquiry.
This is simple stuff and would put determining policies back in the hands of the electorate, not the rich elite. For the first time ever, low turn-out would hit parties financially - the incentive to drive up turn-out would be strong unlike at present where there might actually be an incentive to LOWER turn-out with negative tactics (favoured most by the Right). Add in a fair (proportional) voting system to fair funding - where every vote counts equally, and power really would be returned to the people - anyway enough dreaming - back to the reality of continual grind against the distorted system we have that delivers perpetual Tory and Labour governments that the majority vote against.
22 August 2008
You Can't Have It Both Ways.
Just noticed this piece of genius footage over at Devil's Kitchen. I love DK's suspicion of authority, believe it or not I share the same distrust of the police etc - but if you are going to defend the right to film in a public place (which I also agree with), you cannot go around slagging off CCTV like these 'libertarians' do. They are inconsistent and they must know their argument on CCTV doesn't stand up at all from a libertarian point of view.
12 August 2008
Small State Conservatism?
One for you daily mail reading 'libertarians' out there, all voting for a Tory government to stop Tory councils spying on you and fining you for dumping your rubbish or for not picking up your dog's mess.
It seems the Tories want to scrap rules on having to get permission before they spy on you. You really are going to get what you asked for - you dimwits.
It seems the Tories want to scrap rules on having to get permission before they spy on you. You really are going to get what you asked for - you dimwits.
02 July 2008
TORIES ARE 'ECONOMICAL WITH THE TRUTH' ABOUT GUN CRIME
I missed this...
press release from last year from the GUN CONTROL NETWORK - it is so good,, cannot resist printing it in full here.
4 October 2007
BEFORE AND DURING the Conservative Party conference the two Davids - Cameron and Davis - have repeatedly referred to gun crime as being 'out of control'.
This works as a headline-grabbing statement but it is not true.
These are the facts (figures quoted are for England and Wales):
*
Gun murders remain very low by international standards, with fluctuations between 49 and 97 annually in the last ten years. The most recent provisional figure (for 2006/07) is 58. This compares with 11,624 gun homicides in the USA (in 2004), a rate which is nearly 40 times higher. In France the rate is more than twice that in Britain, in Switzerland over three-fold higher, while in Italy it is over 5 times greater (Source: Global Gun Deaths (Toronto Small Arms/Firearms Education and Research Network, 2005)).
*
The rise in recorded levels of gun crime over the last ten years has been largely due to imitation weapons (3300 more offences per year out of an increase of 9100 offences) and airguns (2500 more offences per year). These figures probably underestimate the number of imitation guns involved.
*
25% of all serious gun injuries are committed with airguns which are still not registered in any way.
*
According to the latest Home Office statistics in the last year gun crime involving every category of gun has fallen e.g. handgun crime is down by 11%. Handgun offences peaked in 2001/02 and have fallen by 30% since then.
It is clear that the Conservatives are whipping up public fear about gun crime for their own narrow political interests. The public interest is not served by these wild and unfounded statements. They are fuelling the 'fear factor' and making the general public more fearful of gun crime than they should be.
Gun crime is a problem, particularly in major cities, and it is true that we need to control guns ever more tightly.
But gun crime is NOT out of control and it is irresponsible of David Cameron and David Davis to suggest it is".
Typical of the Tories - this is the sort of government we are heading for.
4 October 2007
BEFORE AND DURING the Conservative Party conference the two Davids - Cameron and Davis - have repeatedly referred to gun crime as being 'out of control'.
This works as a headline-grabbing statement but it is not true.
These are the facts (figures quoted are for England and Wales):
*
Gun murders remain very low by international standards, with fluctuations between 49 and 97 annually in the last ten years. The most recent provisional figure (for 2006/07) is 58. This compares with 11,624 gun homicides in the USA (in 2004), a rate which is nearly 40 times higher. In France the rate is more than twice that in Britain, in Switzerland over three-fold higher, while in Italy it is over 5 times greater (Source: Global Gun Deaths (Toronto Small Arms/Firearms Education and Research Network, 2005)).
*
The rise in recorded levels of gun crime over the last ten years has been largely due to imitation weapons (3300 more offences per year out of an increase of 9100 offences) and airguns (2500 more offences per year). These figures probably underestimate the number of imitation guns involved.
*
25% of all serious gun injuries are committed with airguns which are still not registered in any way.
*
According to the latest Home Office statistics in the last year gun crime involving every category of gun has fallen e.g. handgun crime is down by 11%. Handgun offences peaked in 2001/02 and have fallen by 30% since then.
It is clear that the Conservatives are whipping up public fear about gun crime for their own narrow political interests. The public interest is not served by these wild and unfounded statements. They are fuelling the 'fear factor' and making the general public more fearful of gun crime than they should be.
Gun crime is a problem, particularly in major cities, and it is true that we need to control guns ever more tightly.
But gun crime is NOT out of control and it is irresponsible of David Cameron and David Davis to suggest it is".
Typical of the Tories - this is the sort of government we are heading for.
Jill Saward Asks Some Important Questions
Jill Saward is standing in the Haltemprice & Howden By-election. While I do not agree with...
everything Jill Saward proposes (especially on increasing the prison population), by supporting an expansion of the DNA database to everyone (far fairer) and improving CCTV quality - that together have already prevented thousands of crimes including many murders and rapes (despite current limitations holding their usefulness back), she does give people a real choice in this election.
If you oppose equal gay rights, support capital punishment, SUPPORT 28 days detention without charge and support some minor reduction in CCTV cameras and the DNA database that will make them less effective tools for catching criminals, then VOTE FOR TORY DAVID DAVIS - Davis has to be the shittest exponent of liberty in recent history to try to stand on a libertarian platform - only a Tory could have the barefaced cheek to misrepresent their real views so spectacularly and seemingly get away with it! (Davis has even been ambivalent about ID cards - voting for them in 2004).
If you support equal gay rights, oppose capital punishment, OPPOSE ANY days detention without trial and dislike CCTV and the DNA database (but seem to have no specific policy on this) then VOTE FOR THE GREEN'S SHAN OAKES.
If you support ID cards, an expansion of the DNA database, better and more widespread use of CCTV, and better support for victims of crime generally, then VOTE FOR JILL SAWARD. Jill asks questions the 'libertarians' can never give a reasonable answer to - like; give real examples of what significant harm CCTV and the DNA database itself (rather than their potential misuse) actually do to people? And why is a theoretical principle worth letting hundreds of murderers and rapists (who do real harm) roam free?
Hopefully these three candidates will not be crowded out by the sheer ridiculous size of the ballot paper crammed as it is with 26 candidates.
It will be hard for the Greens and Jill to make any headway in a safe Tory seat and when the national media and Liberty have given such explicit backing to Davis's supposed 'principled' stand - criminally failing to mention his very illiberal voting record on this issue. As usual the Tories get more than an easy ride from the media.
If you oppose equal gay rights, support capital punishment, SUPPORT 28 days detention without charge and support some minor reduction in CCTV cameras and the DNA database that will make them less effective tools for catching criminals, then VOTE FOR TORY DAVID DAVIS - Davis has to be the shittest exponent of liberty in recent history to try to stand on a libertarian platform - only a Tory could have the barefaced cheek to misrepresent their real views so spectacularly and seemingly get away with it! (Davis has even been ambivalent about ID cards - voting for them in 2004).
If you support equal gay rights, oppose capital punishment, OPPOSE ANY days detention without trial and dislike CCTV and the DNA database (but seem to have no specific policy on this) then VOTE FOR THE GREEN'S SHAN OAKES.
If you support ID cards, an expansion of the DNA database, better and more widespread use of CCTV, and better support for victims of crime generally, then VOTE FOR JILL SAWARD. Jill asks questions the 'libertarians' can never give a reasonable answer to - like; give real examples of what significant harm CCTV and the DNA database itself (rather than their potential misuse) actually do to people? And why is a theoretical principle worth letting hundreds of murderers and rapists (who do real harm) roam free?
Hopefully these three candidates will not be crowded out by the sheer ridiculous size of the ballot paper crammed as it is with 26 candidates.
It will be hard for the Greens and Jill to make any headway in a safe Tory seat and when the national media and Liberty have given such explicit backing to Davis's supposed 'principled' stand - criminally failing to mention his very illiberal voting record on this issue. As usual the Tories get more than an easy ride from the media.
01 July 2008
It Is Easier To Lie Than Tell The Truth.
Following on from these posts here,here and here. Here is my contribution.
If you don't have to properly check your....
If you don't have to properly check your....
facts, if you don't have to be true to yourself - it is much easier to pander to people's prejudices, misconceptions and ignorance. Couple this with widespread control of the media and we can see why right-wing propaganda is so successful - if you say something often enough it catches on. If we say Ken Livingstone is a crook over and over again, most voters will begin to believe it, even if they have no idea what he has supposed to have done and even when he is probably the most honest, competent and hardworking politician of his generation. When you are one voice telling the truth amongst many fibbers - it is the fibbers who will probably win out.
It also takes time to check facts, do proper research and results are never black and white - this is another bugbear of the Left. In this age of 24 hour media and 30 second sound-bites, how do we get across subtle points on complex issues? It is easy for the Right, they just exaggerate, distort, blatantly lie and can repeat these lies until they become mainstream and accepted - it helps them that most media do less than scratch the surface of most subjects - which is partly why religion, racism and other ignorance still exists. The Right have the power to shout the loudest and shout most often to make sure their points are heard - because they own most of the media. Commercial interests are always going to be skewed against the consumer and voter interests. Those who pay the billions in advertising to the media each year are going to call the shots in every debate and it is in their interests to call for lower taxes on the wealthy at the expense of the poorest and for transport, healthcare, education and other public services to provide better services to the middle classes than the majority who are poor.
So how do the Left fight back?
Well most importantly we do have the facts on our side. The Right cannot deny what people see with their own eyes, what they experience in their daily lives, and this is why we need to hand as much power as possible to the people. Democracy is the left-wing friend. The lack of it in the Soviet Union was the reason why socialism could never have succeeded there.
Unfortunately the Labour party has moved towards the Soviet model of socialism i.e. without the democracy - so debate is stifled within the party and members views suppressed, membership falls as members are seen more as a nuisance than an asset. Why have Labour done this? When faced with the power of a distorting media and electoral system and the wealthy business class who control the economy, the Labour response was understandable - they decided to play by the right-wing rules of the game - so they could not just flittingly win power for one term but stay there. For a decade this has sort of worked, the economy was kept benign and the wealthy untroubled. This enabled much social change on equalities for minorities, doubling of public sector spending on health and education and worker protection, even tentative freedom of information rules. For all the talk of Tories being libertarian, don't be surprised if the FOI rules are the first to go. It is laughable that an anti-gay, hang 'em, flog 'em Tory is now being lauded by the head of Liberty - like their support for speeding drivers and opposition to ID cards, CCTV and DNA databases, it shows how their priorities have been skewed into theoretical perfection rather than practical improvements in people's lives. Their support for David Davis rather than the Greens who are the true libertarian standard holders in the by-election, takes them beyond even this stupidity into the realms of courting right-wing popular-ism - even Liberty cannot deny the power of the right-wing press.
So for all the admirable progress of this Labour government, unless they embrace democracy, it is likely to be lost to a Tory government elected by a small minority of the electorate. I find it difficult to understand how or why the manifesto commitment on PR was avoided by a Labour government in power for a decade. It is clear that enough Tories and dimwits have infected the party to take it away from the true will of the people. Even now, Labour could put this right - but it is just not going to happen. To change to PR and prevent this right-wing government being imposed once again on a reluctant public would be the first step on the road to a socialist fight-back. All we can do in the party is keep making the argument - elect Ann Black to the NEC, and offer an inclusion of PR in the 'partnership in power' documents being drawn up this week.
It is sad to see the slow death of a Labour government that could be out of power for another generation as the Tories alter boundaries in their favour and abolish the broadcast rules on impartiality. The real losers are not the Labour party, but the people, they can see corporate interests override the majority and feel powerless to stop it - just like in the good 'ol US of A. The land of the free - my ar**!
It also takes time to check facts, do proper research and results are never black and white - this is another bugbear of the Left. In this age of 24 hour media and 30 second sound-bites, how do we get across subtle points on complex issues? It is easy for the Right, they just exaggerate, distort, blatantly lie and can repeat these lies until they become mainstream and accepted - it helps them that most media do less than scratch the surface of most subjects - which is partly why religion, racism and other ignorance still exists. The Right have the power to shout the loudest and shout most often to make sure their points are heard - because they own most of the media. Commercial interests are always going to be skewed against the consumer and voter interests. Those who pay the billions in advertising to the media each year are going to call the shots in every debate and it is in their interests to call for lower taxes on the wealthy at the expense of the poorest and for transport, healthcare, education and other public services to provide better services to the middle classes than the majority who are poor.
So how do the Left fight back?
Well most importantly we do have the facts on our side. The Right cannot deny what people see with their own eyes, what they experience in their daily lives, and this is why we need to hand as much power as possible to the people. Democracy is the left-wing friend. The lack of it in the Soviet Union was the reason why socialism could never have succeeded there.
Unfortunately the Labour party has moved towards the Soviet model of socialism i.e. without the democracy - so debate is stifled within the party and members views suppressed, membership falls as members are seen more as a nuisance than an asset. Why have Labour done this? When faced with the power of a distorting media and electoral system and the wealthy business class who control the economy, the Labour response was understandable - they decided to play by the right-wing rules of the game - so they could not just flittingly win power for one term but stay there. For a decade this has sort of worked, the economy was kept benign and the wealthy untroubled. This enabled much social change on equalities for minorities, doubling of public sector spending on health and education and worker protection, even tentative freedom of information rules. For all the talk of Tories being libertarian, don't be surprised if the FOI rules are the first to go. It is laughable that an anti-gay, hang 'em, flog 'em Tory is now being lauded by the head of Liberty - like their support for speeding drivers and opposition to ID cards, CCTV and DNA databases, it shows how their priorities have been skewed into theoretical perfection rather than practical improvements in people's lives. Their support for David Davis rather than the Greens who are the true libertarian standard holders in the by-election, takes them beyond even this stupidity into the realms of courting right-wing popular-ism - even Liberty cannot deny the power of the right-wing press.
So for all the admirable progress of this Labour government, unless they embrace democracy, it is likely to be lost to a Tory government elected by a small minority of the electorate. I find it difficult to understand how or why the manifesto commitment on PR was avoided by a Labour government in power for a decade. It is clear that enough Tories and dimwits have infected the party to take it away from the true will of the people. Even now, Labour could put this right - but it is just not going to happen. To change to PR and prevent this right-wing government being imposed once again on a reluctant public would be the first step on the road to a socialist fight-back. All we can do in the party is keep making the argument - elect Ann Black to the NEC, and offer an inclusion of PR in the 'partnership in power' documents being drawn up this week.
It is sad to see the slow death of a Labour government that could be out of power for another generation as the Tories alter boundaries in their favour and abolish the broadcast rules on impartiality. The real losers are not the Labour party, but the people, they can see corporate interests override the majority and feel powerless to stop it - just like in the good 'ol US of A. The land of the free - my ar**!
25 June 2008
Vote Green In Haltemprice & Howden By-election.
As Labour are too chicken, the Libertarian Party are a joke who cannot even field a candidate in a by-election specifically on liberty issues and the Lib Dems back a hang 'em, flog 'em, opposer of gay rights Tory candidate called David Davis, then that only leaves one national party who are standing on a true-ish liberal platform - and that is the Green party. Vote Green if you want to make a point on detention with charge - even one day is too many - remember David Davis supports 28 days detention without charge.
More here from pickled politics.
More here from pickled politics.
24 June 2008
Zimbabwe Exemplifies Why Iraq Was About Oil.
I reckon George Bush could win back the faith of Europeans simply by launching an invasion of Zimbabwe and removing Mugabe from power (mobile footage of Mugabe hanging would be more popular than...
the demise of Saddam).
Here is a country clearly being despotised amid universal world condemnation. When Bush invaded Iraq, he brushed aside the condemnation of Iraq's neighbours, he ignored the UN, all he needed was his 'moral crusade' (or so they told us). The objections of Zimbabwe's neighbours could equally be ignored.
It was obvious even to a child that Iraq was no threat (intelligence on Iraqi weapons was comprehensive - the gulf war and Israeli/US air attacks had completely disabled Iraq and everyone knew their rockets could not reach Europe), the weapons inspectors would have confirmed there were no WMD within weeks if the invasion had been delayed. But Bush rushed ahead. If Bush invades Zimbabwe in the next few months he would prove me wrong. But until that dubious day, I can only conclude 'oil crusade' not 'moral crusade' was the real agenda.
Here is a country clearly being despotised amid universal world condemnation. When Bush invaded Iraq, he brushed aside the condemnation of Iraq's neighbours, he ignored the UN, all he needed was his 'moral crusade' (or so they told us). The objections of Zimbabwe's neighbours could equally be ignored.
It was obvious even to a child that Iraq was no threat (intelligence on Iraqi weapons was comprehensive - the gulf war and Israeli/US air attacks had completely disabled Iraq and everyone knew their rockets could not reach Europe), the weapons inspectors would have confirmed there were no WMD within weeks if the invasion had been delayed. But Bush rushed ahead. If Bush invades Zimbabwe in the next few months he would prove me wrong. But until that dubious day, I can only conclude 'oil crusade' not 'moral crusade' was the real agenda.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
