Showing posts with label Inequality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Inequality. Show all posts

06 February 2014

IFS says tax base is too dependent on rich few, but real problem is inequality

In Thomas Piketty's new book "Capitalism in the 21st century", he argues that the rise in inequality is inescapable and will reach double the present levels.

In 30 years the top 1% have gone from owning 13% of total wealth to 30%. In the next 30 years this could reach 60%.

A new IFS report says the UK income tax base is unstable because it depends too much on just 300,000 people - the richest 1% contributing 30% of revenue.

But tax rates on the rich have actually fallen and rates on the poor have risen. Without reducing the total tax take overall, rising inequality means this concentration of revenue collection on the rich few is inevitable and cutting tax and spending which by nature tends to be redistributive will only accelerate inequality. We are stuck in a self fulfilling catch 22 that is very convenient for the Right.

The IFS also criticise the government for reducing the overall tax base by pushing up the income tax threshold to £10,000.

Yet this has been the one piece of good news for below living wage earners. Yes I know it is a poorly targeted way of helping low earners, but at least it was a pro "make work pay" policy and continuing to heavily tax subsistence level incomes makes no social sense.

So what is the solution and can we be more optimistic about inequality than Piketty argues?

The free movement of capital around the globe is increasingly defeating tax collection at national level and favourable tax policies and other "big corp" legislation are bought cheaply from our weak political systems. This is the main thrust of Piketty's pessimistic view - (although two world wars depleting the wealthy's assets temporarily turned the tide).

Piketty argues that nation states can only hold back the rising tide of inequality in the short term because the wealthy can move capital around the globe and continually play one nation off against another. So the only hope to combat this are supranational organisations like the EU.

It is ironic that those wealthy few who control the financial markets argue against the EU's single currency on the basis that social justice & economic efficiency in the Eurozone require significant fiscal cooperation between nations. Yet this equally applies to free movement of global capital or free trade agreements, yet the EU is the only organisation with a significant supranational structure to tackle this problem (inadequate though those structures may be).

On the tax base issue, the IFS argues correctly that increasing the National Insurance threshold is a better way of helping low earners than the Income Tax threshold (though this doesn't expand the tax base).

It seems to me that if we are hamstrung and unable to use taxes to reduce inequality, then Miliband's idea of "predistribution" is even more pertinant. Politically useful in an era of austerity ideology where tax and spend are anathema, Miliband could smash monopolies and regulate prices and wages to redistribute wealth. The wealthy will of course spend heavily to vilify this approach.

Personally, I still think a radical overhaul of tax & benefits are required to make a real difference - the government currently spend £720bn a year. I would scrap all spending bar the £130bn on health, £30bn on social care, £90bn on education, £30bn on justice, £30bn transport & £50bn debt interest. I would allow £50bn more for infrastructure and miscellaneous. This leaves £310bn to pay every worker, pensioner, disabled & unemployed person cash of £6,900pa each. Extra revenue could be raised by scrapping all tax allowances (raises £90bn) which would increase payment to £8,900pa (£740 per month).

This would extend the tax base to all workers, as all earnings would be subject to tax and NI. It would provide a subsistence amount to every adult to live and because there is no means testing remove all admin costs and it would encourage work as there would be no benefit loss to taking work. Very few would not want to supplement a subsistence amount by working. Those people generally are on benefits already anyway. The incentives would now be clear, every pound you earn would make you better off.

I would also look to build housing for profit to pay down the national debt by buying cheap agricultural land (£8k an acre), then grant planning permission thus turning it into £1m per acre overnight. Then build houses & infrastructure with the revenue and sell for big profit. Just 0.5m acres (0.4% of UK's 60m acres) would provide ample space for 4m new homes. Land profit from granting planning permission could generate £400bn in revenue for infrastructure, house building and paying down national debt. I think thats a better option than trying to pay off a £1.2trn national debt by hitting the poorest 10% of people who only have assets of £8bn. The assets of the richest 10% are £4000bn.

Time we had a proper debate on this rather than the poor excuse for a debate we get in our corporate owned (& government bullied publicly owned) media.

04 November 2013

Why A Minimum Wage/Living Wage Is A Sticking Plaster Not The Solution To Poverty Pay.

It is a good thing that Ed Miliband is talking about a living wage and pledging to use tax breaks as an incentive to employers who pay it. But it isn't going to be enough to address the root cause of poverty - a massive widening in inequality.

Sadly even well meaning employers cannot afford to subsidise the poor having to pay rip off rents, exorbitant debt fuelled house prices and the rip off prices of privatised monopolies. Not to mention the unnecessary taxes that hit poverty pay hard.

Wages can only rise as far as productive value will allow. There is some scope as many jobs pay below their true value. The Tory horror stories of mass job losses from having a minimum wage have proved false.

But equally we shouldn't be taxing people earning less than the living wage. What we should be taxing are speculators, whether builders who profit more from sitting on land than building on it or casino bankers and traders who do nothing socially or economically useful.

It is time for a land value tax and a financial transaction tax to largely replace the stupidity of taxing things we should be encouraging - i.e. jobs, especially as only the little people pay income taxes and corporation taxes.

And despite the media onslaught, we should also help those with little or no work. In the US, attacking the poor is so advanced that even working 80 hours a week to make ends meet is not enough to avoid a "lazy" tag. The ideology where only the individual is king of their rise or demise has to be challenged. It is the lazy system that destroys lives not lazy individuals.

A basic income unconditionally paid to all will remove the financial disincentive to work. Pay workers the dole and no-one loses by taking a job.

But most of all we need a massive public housing programme to address an acute shortage that now afflicts 100s of thousands but in 20 years will affect 10s of millions.

Ed Miliband is right to enter this debate and it is progress that it is on the agenda, but the solutions require more than just scratching the surface of pay.

21 April 2013

13 Reasons Why Thatcher Did Not Incentivise Work Or Help The Skilled Working Class.

This I think is the key claim of those who support Thatcherism. That skilled workers who put in long hours (social class C2) do better with a deregulated, privatised, deunionised Thatcherite Britain than they would with a more equal socialised economy/society.

There are a number of reasons why this claim is false; here is my list.

1. Under Thatcherism more money was/is made from speculative profit than from hard work.

Only those skilled workers who poured their earnings into property & shares did well & a lot had to take on unrealistic debt. Only those already with large wealth could make a killing.

It was the speculative profit that was the real gain. And even then large parts of this might have gone in debt repayment as interest rates were high under Thatcher. And the risk of default & repossession from a boom.& bust economy & precarious insecure employment that go with that were real.

2. Any gains were short term.

Only one generation could benefit from higher house prices & quick profits from state sell offs and only at the expense of future generations. Plus the gains were very unevenly distributed. Those with large inherited wealth benefited most without having to do even a day's work.

3. Large geographic differences.

Born north of Watford? Then things were a lot harder to jump on the speculative bonanza being had down south.

4. Privatised monopolies have led to higher prices for basic essentials.

Gas, electric, water & public transport have all seen disproportionate increases in prices. Profits now go abroad ironically to foreign governments who now own our utilities.

The burden of paying for these monopoly services has moved from the taxpayer to consumers with profits now syphoned off abroad rather than re-invested in long term infrastructure.

Private companies (or in this case foreign governments) have no incentive to invest for the long term and every incentive to take short term profits for fear of future re-nationalisation. So worse service & higher costs. Same is now happening to healthcare

5. Every pound made from debt is a pound taken from the real productive economy.

Those with money to lend tend not to spend it all. In long run debts have to be paid back with considerable interest. This obviously removes demand from economy. Especially if lenders are based abroad.

6. A lot of wealth & profit went abroad.

Nearly all privatised industries are now majority owned by overseas companies/governments.

7. 'In work' welfare was cut back making work less worthwhile.

Reduce incomes of low paid "entry" level jobs and people make rational decision that financial incentive is not enough. Difficult to get people off welfare once this mindset is ingrained over long period.

Less healthcare provision & poorer quality state education, cutbacks in tax credits & other universal benefits. These all make work relatively less attractive. As do rocketing costs of housing & other basics ( see point 4).

8. De-unionisation lowered wages for all, including self employed tradesmen.

Increased downward pressure on wages of skilled workers. Best demonstrated by building workers strike. All builders got pay rise from this.

9. Lowered 'out of work' welfare, meant people had to work for less.

Higher welfare benefits mean higher wages have to be paid. The minimum wage has shown that this does not necessarily mean less jobs available. A lot of jobs have wages below their true value & most jobs here cannot easily be moved abroad. e.g. Care workers, builders etc. Besides, we can never set wages lower than developing countries, so any jobs that can be moved, already have been.

10. Skilled working class were more affected by crime, disorder & environmental degradation.

The bankers making tens of millions speculating up food prices causing hardship for billions just fled abroad when they could to escape the social chaos their financial rape of their home country had caused. Mere 'plebs' cannot do this.

11. Regressive taxation.

Moving the burden of taxation onto indirect taxes & council tax hit 90% of workers who are not in top tax bracket.

12. Skilled workers who worked hard in socially useful but what Thatcher deemed were economically unproductive trades/professions were deincentivised with lower pay.

13. Longer hours & more stressed lives.

At the end of the day, surplus possessions mean little if your whole quality of life has deteriorated. Living in a more unequal society has destroyed community & led to isolated lives with higher social problems - crime, drugs, obesity teenage pregnancies. See the Spirit Level book for more about the damage Thatcher did.

10 April 2013

Margaret Thatcher: The Worst PM In History?

First of all, if you want specific reasons why I hate Thatcher - go here for a list.

This post is my deeper philosophical look at her impact.

By "worst PM" I don't mean she was ineffective or wasn't a success. Sadly she succeeded all too well in her aims. Neither was she lazy, I have to admit she worked hard. Nor do I deny her achievements in getting to be leader of a bunch of reactionary Tory men in a sexist country and first female PM in the Western world.

Nor do I claim she was thick, she clearly could think, which makes what she did to this country all the more cruel. She had no excuses, and I think she was the worst PM because she took power when Britain was at its most equal and happy and turned it into the most unequal & miserable it had been since the 1930s.

The question mark in the title is because it is so difficult to gauge the impact of PMs from pre 20th century, and there were bound to be cruel bastards of outrageous vindictiveness that surpassed even Thatcher.

But definitely in recent memory and probably in the last 100 years, no PM did as much damage to society and the economy as Thatcher because no other PM started from such a good base and had such fortuitous times to waste. Which she did in spades. This needs explaining in detail because the myths of the 70s and Labour and the unions of that time are so deep.

First of all, oil! Thatcher had trillions of barrels of the stuff and it was coming on stream just at a time when oil prices were going through the roof. Imagine the disadvantages of Germany & France who had to import this costly stuff. This was an unbelievablr bonus of immense proportions and Thatcher wasted it all.

Secondly, the trillions of revenue created by selling off most state assets from houses to utilities. Prized assets that would have been of benefit to all for generations to come, blown in one decade splurge!

Third, expansion of private credit by abolishing controls. This also provided ammunition for Thatcher to do amazing investment projects if she had directed private investment as such. Not as if this reckless deregulation should have happened at all of course. As we have found out recently with the global financial crash but I'll be generous in saying there was global pressure to do this.

Fourthly the unions. Surely the stifling of innovation, which was indeed the biggest crime they were guilty of, was something Thatcher did well to overcome?

Well the question that should be posed is; did technological change and efficient organisation of industry really need unions completely defeated and manufacturing smashed?

That was certainly the costly route Thatcher took, but could we have took the more co-operative route of Germany & Sweden whose manufacturing is still most advanced & organised in Europe despite being completely unionised?

The answer to this second question is almost certainly yes. The money was there from the 3 massive revenue streams already mentioned to buy off unions and members and invest long term in R&D with a fair share of this wealth.

Don't get me wrong, it wouldn't have been easy, what with acrimonious relations and bone headed union leadership averse to change, but we could have saved whole manufacturing industries and at much less cost in terms of both financial costs of unemployment and blighted communities and cheaper and safer than relying on imports or starting industries from scratch years later.

Of course, maybe this would have needed a Labour government in 1983 or at least a return of a one nation kind of Conservatives a la Heath to see what they could with the oil revenue they both so badly needed earlier in the 70s to save Britain.

And another side effect of non-privatisation and renewed building of decent social housing and long term investment in utilities would have been cheaper costs for workers which has side effect of making work pay. A lot of welfare lifestyles would never of happened. With all the immense economic and social costs of crime and breakdown.

At this point, I can hear a lot of rightwingers sneering that without the break in post-war consensus that Thatcher brought and with it, all the "private enterprise", modernisation couldn't have happened. We would still be paying enormous fees to inefficient unresponsive state owned monoliths taking weeks to install a phone. But this is bollocks!

A lot of technological advances were attributed to Thatcher, yet were completely coincidental. A mobile phone was the size of a car and cost a million pounds in 1979, yet the usable mobiles of the 90s had nothing to do with privatisation. If BT had still been state owned we wouldn't be mobile free.

But the bigger argument is what happened to the much smaller scale industry and manufacturing in France that never went through the "Thatcher revolutuon". State owned companies were supported, they innovated and thrived. Manufacturing was not only protected, it grew in France and diversified. They have a growing successful electronics industry, still have THREE French owned car manufacturers when we have no British owned and more components producers. Like I say, all from a tiny base when we had massive advantages. All the workers skills we had, have been lost. But best of all France did this and paid its workers handsomely and kept its unions strong.

The devastation wreaked on industrial Northern and Midlands Britain was largely avoided in industrialised parts of France which re-invented itself.

And to cap it all France is still managing better growth now. None of the so called handicaps of unions and high wages are making France do worse than us. They manage better productivity and socially and economically are in a much better place.

That was a long digression I know but I hope you understand why it was needed. And there are other examples of how state support for industries in other countries was a success contrary to Thatcher doctrine, e.g. in South Korea and Japan.

So to other advantages that Thatcher had - social cohesion.

Surveys have long suggested the 70s were the happiest times in Britain. There were real communities that were destroyed and crime doubled under Thatcher as inequality spiralled. This community spirit could have performed real good. The fight against climate change and properly funded public transport could have built new towns for the eco age instead of run down new spaced out box estates filled with speeding cars mowing down pedestrians and cyclists.

The doing everything on the cheap and short termism of Thatcher's Britain meant our people got miserable as their quality of life and environment deteriorated.

Then there was the health of the nation. One of the first things I remember is the meanness of Thatcher's decision to take my milk as a 5 year old while she was Education minister. Regardless of the health implications, it was depressing. Then as I left school she removed dentistry & optometry from the NHS, removing the habit of going to the dentist or opticians for millions scared at the cost with predictable results.

The car dependency culture accelerated and exercising got more difficult and unpleasant as open green safe spaces disappeared from working class areas and even schools causing obesity and boredom or stress. Even schools gave up and the food industry deteriorated into pushing the most unhealthy cheap food on our children as Thatcher removed regulations.

Life got shitter for the poor and work was less worthwhile as welfare provided basics workers had had taken away. The counter productive stupidity of all this seemed lost on Thatcher. As she struggled to understand the growth of the underclass she was creating. She turned to moral crusades but her ministers own hypocrisy undermined that.

Finally, the deregulation of finance. This obviously was global and led from the US, but Thatcher could not understand the harm in allowing banks to push debt onto an increasingly desperate poor surrounded by consumerist temptation. As Chris Dillow put it, Thatcher expected the restraint of her dad, not the profligacy of her son.

And the corruption of finance, the cosying up to gangster press barons, and police state of Thatcher told us she was closer to totalitarian Soviets than she ever was to this mythical freedom that the most vicious uncaring capitalists proselytise to the poor about.

So what does all this tell us about how Thatcher changed Britain? (Cos she certainly did). What is her legacy. Can it be summed up with a simple phrase? Well the closest I think is; for all her talk of morality & restraint her philosophy was actually the opposite. Unrestrained immorality. Money over humanity. We need to get back what is really important - people having fun in each other's company. Interactive quality of life, not quantity of possesions! Making money IS important, just not at the price that Thatcher & her next generation of Tories place on it. Nowhere near.

Pages